Invite friends and family to read the obituary and add memories.
We'll notify you when service details or new memories are added.
You're now following this obituary
We'll email you when there are updates.
Select your format and elements to print
Anthony L. "Tony"
Gaglione III
May 11, 1941 — Jun 26, 2026
Monday
Our Lady of Mount Carmel Basilica
Starts at 11:00 am (Eastern time)
Willoughby, Ohio - Anthony Leonard "Tony" Gaglione III, 85, of Willoughby, Ohio, formerly of Youngstown, passed away Friday morning, June 26, 2026.
Tony lived life with a big smile, a quick wit, and a way of making everyone feel welcome. Whether you knew him for years or had just met him, Tony had a knack for making people laugh and enjoy the moment. He will be remembered for his hard work, his friendships, and above all, the love he had for his family.
Born on May 11, 1941, in Youngstown, Ohio, Tony was the son of Anthony Gaglione Jr. and Edith Agnes (Marsch) Gaglione. Proud of his roots on the East Side of Youngstown and his Italian heritage, he remained deeply connected to his family throughout his life, keeping close relationships even with second and third cousins.
Tony graduated from East High School before proudly serving his country in the United States Army from February 1960 until April 1962. While stationed in Hawaii and the Philippines, tragedy struck when his father passed away. At just 20 years old, Tony returned home to take over the family restaurant and bar, the Blue Jay Inn.
Alongside his lifelong friend Anthony Cicchi and business partner Edward Cronin, Tony owned and operated several local establishments, including one of Youngstown's most beloved gathering places, Tony's Hideaway. He later built a successful career in construction and land development. He remained active in business until retiring just a few years ago after selling Starr Centre Plaza.
On November 16, 1984, Tony married the love of his life, the former Gail Bierdman, with whom he shared countless memories, adventures, and joy.
Tony's first passion was hunting and fishing, creating memories on countless trips with his son, sons-in-law, grandchildren, cousins, and friends. Summers were highlighted by unforgettable Fourth of July parties during the 1990s that brought together family, neighbors, and friends for food, laughter, and celebration.
He also enjoyed making homemade wine alongside his friend Anthony DeGeorge, proudly entering their creations into local competitions. At home, he loved working on puzzles with his daughters, was an avid reader, and spent countless Sundays cheering for the Cleveland Browns. Even at the casino, Tony had an uncanny ability to turn strangers at the card table into friends before the night was over.
Tony was a devoted member of St. Jude Parish in Columbiana and the Mahoning Valley Duck Club.
He is survived by his loving wife, Gail (Bierdeman) Gaglione; his children: TJ Gaglione (Rochelle); Michelle DeRose (John); Karen Markulin (Dave); Renee Oddo, (Vinnie); Dana Moses (Norm); and Gabrielle Sabatino (Michael). He also leaves behind twelve grandchildren: Joey, Bryan, Alexandra, Adrianna, Carlie, Michael M., Anthony, Santino, Mya, Sienna, Michael S., and Mariah; four great-grandchildren, Mia, Maverick, Sophia, and Sloane, with another great-grandchild expected soon. Tony is also survived by his brother-in-law, Leonard Schwenneker, sister-in-law Debbie Bierdeman and brothers-in-law Mark Bierdeman (Cindy), Brad Bierdeman (Becky), John Bierdeman (Ginger) and countless cousins, hunting partners, and dear friends whose lives were brighter because they knew him.
He was preceded in death by his parents; his sister, Rosanne Schwenneker; his lifelong best friend, Anthony Cicchi; his mother-in-law, Sally Bierdeman; his brother-in-law, Tom Bierdeman and his son-in-law, Vinnie Oddo.
Family and friends are welcome to attend a Funeral Mass that will be held on Monday, July 6, 2026, at 11:00 am at Our Lady of Mount Carmel Basilica, 343 Via Mount Carmel, Youngstown, Ohio. There are no calling hours, and everyone is asked to meet directly at the church.
Burial will take place at Calvary Cemetery, Youngstown where military honors will be performed by the great men and women of the Ellsworth VFW Post 9571.
Arrangements are entrusted to the professional care of the Rossi & Santucci Funeral Home, 4221 Market St., Boardman.
Tony believed the best parts of life were meant to be shared with family, friends, good food, and good conversation. He worked hard, cared deeply about the people around him, and was always ready with a story or a laugh. His family hopes he'll be remembered not only for what he did, but for the way he lived. In his honor, gather with the people you love, share a good story, raise a glass, and enjoy the time you have together.
The family respectfully requests that, in lieu of flowers, memorial donations be made to the charity or nonprofit organization of the donor’s choice.
Family and friends may visit www.rossisantuccifh.com to view this obituary and share condolences with Tony’s family
Visits: 166
This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the
Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
Service map data © OpenStreetMap contributors